My first ever NY style pizza & I got to try both the thin slice & their square slice. I preferred the square slice, but both were very good. The whole pizza is the large round. Super friendly & funny staff. There wasn't a long wait when we arrived either.

I love the Sicilian slices from this place and it's what they're known for and they have been in this location for years. The sauce is amazing, The cheese is fresh and the crust is perfect. When I go I usually walk up to the window for my slices and there's a separate window to order if you want a whole pie. They have outdoor picnic tables and also have indoor seating but I've never used anything other than the outdoor seating. Overall this is an actual place of visit if you're a fan of pizza and you like Sicilian slices too like me

Had dinner here last Saturday with my bf and really enjoyed ourselves! It's a straight up Italian-American restaurant with New York-style pizza, the famous Sicilian pizza, pasta, seafood, salads, heros, and spumoni - and there's a takeout counter as well as an eat-in dining area. We ordered a Sicilian pizza with half marinara sauce, half vodka sauce and pepperoni, and the fried calamari, and were impressed with all of it. The calamari was fresh and not overcooked and the batter was wonderfully light and crispy. Summery and fresh tasting. I really enjoyed it. I'd thought the vodka sauce on the Sicilian pizza sounded sort of like a gimmick, but it was delicious! And I'm happy to say the regular Sicilian slice lives up to its reputation. We were too full to get pasta or heros or dessert, but will be back for more!

This new spot in Dumbo and second location of the pizza institution is incredible! Everything about it is delicious, warm, and welcoming, with a big space that’s great for groups. Shoutout to the kindest, coolest server Rodney! Their Sicilian pizza is insane. Thick and doughy, unlike any crust I’ve had before, almost half-baked in the middle like a great cookie. Their sauce is sweet and comforting and their baked clams were delicious. Of course, you’ve gotta get the spumoni ice cream for dessert - its marzipan flavor and crunch is unlike any spumoni I’ve had. Can’t wait to come back to try their regular pizza, a salad, and more of that spumoni. 5 stars!!!!

L&B Spumoni is a classic spot known for its legendary square slice—and in my opinion, the best white slice I’ve had. It was my first visit, though my husband has been raving about it for ages. While there’s seating available, we opted for takeout and enjoyed our slices with a park view. Service was quick and efficient.

I've wanted to try Spumoni Gardens for a while. I'm a big fan of Sicilian pizza, any pizza really, and I've heard great things. This new location was much closer to where I was so I came here. I've never been to the original so I can't compare, but this was an excellent Sicilian! Service was quick and friendly and the quality was fantastic. I also really appreciate the small counter to sit and eat at if you don't plan on dining in.

Pizza is awesome and never disappoints!!! But for the first time I tried the seafood and it was so fresh and delicious! We had the seafood salad and the mussels. The red sauce was sooo good and we also tried the artichokes. Dessert was phenomenal, the Spumoni ice cream and the tiramisu was delicious. We didn’t have one bad dish. I absolutely recommend. Dominic our waiter was the best!

We had a giant salad and rigatoni with garlic and broccoli excellent I really wanted pizza but didn’t have room we also had the meatball appetizer and of course spumoni for dessert.